Letter to My Nieces on the Election of President Trump

CHW Logo

I’ve been thinking about you two a lot recently, especially when I saw the election results.  It’s probably always challenging to be an almost 11 year old girl, but especially now.  Living in Florida, you’ve certainly seen a lot that was said during this election campaign, no matter how hard your mom might have tried to shield you from it.  And a lot of what was said was ugly, on all sides.  Now, this isn’t about Mr. Trump per se, and I don’t want to talk about what kind of president he might be (you also certainly know that there are many widely varying opinions about that, including within our own family).  I want to talk about what I think this election means for girls and women.

When your mother and I were growing up, it was the era of “women’s liberation.”  Since the early days of this country, there have been laws oppressing women: keeping them from voting, owning property, and in general participating fully in society.  By the 1960s and 70s, many of those legal barriers were gone.  But it was still generally assumed that women were simply not as qualified as men.  (We were lucky to have a mother – your Nana –  that defied those stereotypes.)   And just because women were no longer legally second-class citizens didn’t mean they were treated the same.  Liberty is not the same as freedom; attitudes can hold people back as effectively as laws.  So many women, and many men, worked to change those attitudes.  They also worked to enact laws to counteract the discrimination that came from those attitudes.  For example, even though many people thought sports were only for boys, Title IX meant that schools couldn’t only invest in boys’ sports – they had to provide equal opportunities for girls.  And gradually, things got better.  Not perfect – women still earned less than men, were less likely to be leaders in government and business, and frequently judged by different and stricter standards – but better.  Or so I thought.

A few things became clear during the past year or so.  First, when a woman (Hillary Clinton) and a man (Donald Trump) try to do the same thing, they are still judged very differently.  In particular, Americans still have a very “masculine” view of leadership and strength.  People can be strong in many, many ways.  (Just look at your grandmother.)  But it seems when we are electing a leader, we focus only on the kinds of strength – being pushy, brash, in-your-face – that are traditionally associated with boys and men.  It’s another one of those attitudes that is holding women back.  And I’m not sure that’s actually the right kind of strength for a leader.  Look at Vladimir Putin versus Angela Merkel – I’d take Merkel any day.

What’s more disturbing is that not only is the attitude that women are not as qualified as men still quite common, but so is the attitude that women aren’t as good as men, not worth as much.  That they are in many ways simply objects for men.  During the recent campaign we heard people say things about women that I didn’t think many people actually thought, much less said out loud, much less did.  And worse, we heard so many stories from women who said yes, they had heard it and seen it and experienced it.  The leers, the comments, the put-downs, the touches.  As a man I have never had to put up with what all the women I know say has happened to them.  And as a man I am ashamed for those other men.

Now, very few people actually said this sexual harassment was a good thing (though shockingly some did), and I know that most people who voted for Mr. Trump don’t believe it’s good.  Some people dismissed it as “just talk.”  Others said that’s just what guys do.  And many said yes, it’s bad, but we’re going to ignore it because nobody is perfect, and there are more important issues like security or the economy that we agree with him on.  It’s true no one is perfect – certainly Ms. Clinton isn’t – and we have to view people as a whole package of traits, some admirable and some not.  But there are some things that you can’t ignore: sexual harassment and assault is one of them.  You can’t minimize it, or trivialize it, or excuse it, or rationalize it because at least the trains are running on time.  By doing that, it sends the message that it’s only a little bad.

Which is why I was thinking of you on election night.  Obviously, if Ms. Clinton had won, that would have been a strong positive message for girls and women.  I worry that the message in Mr. Trump’s election is that mistreating , demeaning, and even abusing women is not so bad.  In fact, it may even be good – after all, it shows the kind of strength you need to lead.  Which means things are worse for women than I thought, and that makes me sorry and scared for you.

So know a few things.  First, degrading women is not OK.  It’s wrong.  Always.  Period.

Second, everyone has inherent worth and dignity.  Everyone deserves to be respected.  Don’t ever let anyone deny you that.  Be strong.

Third, it’s not something that all guys do or talk about.  I don’t, your cousins don’t, and most men don’t.  Sexism and misogyny are not carried on the Y chromosome.  They are learned, and they can be unlearned (or better, prevented).

I’m not going to send you this yet.  I wanted to get it off my chest, but I’m going to save this until I think you’re ready.  My sincere hope is that when I send it to you in 10 years or so, things will be better.  That no one will assume what you can and can’t do because you’re a girl.  That you’ll be treated fairly and with respect.  That you won’t have to deal with a demeaning boyfriend, or a creepy boss or colleague.  That no guy will brush up against you or press up against you or grab you.  That you won’t ever be a victim of “date” rape.  I hope that board rooms and legislatures and other halls of power will look like America, and not like an NHL hockey team.  I hope all those things.  But hope is not a plan.  So also know that you have people – women and men, like your aunt and your cousins and me –  who are going to fight like hell to make it so.

17 Responses to Letter to My Nieces on the Election of President Trump

  1. Mary Geoghan says:

    Marc thank you for your thoughts- I am thankful that you as a person and leader are grounded with respect for all. Your nieces will certainly be in awe of your words at a future date. But know, they will not
    Be surprised at the man (uncle) you are.

  2. Cassie Ferguson says:

    Thank you, Marc. I needed to hear that.

  3. Chris Schindler says:

    Thank you Marc. Great to have this time of respect modeled within the CHW leadership.

  4. Chris Schindler says:

    Thank you Marc. Glad to have this public display of support here at CHW.

  5. Allison Gassaro says:

    Great read cuz! Defer to beth but they ARE ready to read this and I will share with Georgie! Love and miss u!

    Sent from my iPhone

  6. Pam Johnson says:

    Thank you this is an important message.

  7. Liz Alexander says:

    Bravo! Thank you!

  8. Jennifer Hammel says:

    I so appreciate you, an honorable, trustworthy man, discernible leader and passionate physician and advocate, sharing this message. Please don’t wait 10 years to share this with your nieces. These are important messages girls need to hear before young boys who don’t know any better start to behave in these ways. Your nieces can be empowered by your words to stand up for themselves or engage adults to stand up for them if the power struggle is too uneven to stand up on their own.

  9. julietski says:

    I always appreciate your thoughts. Today’s comments really hit the mark.

  10. Diane Bauer says:

    Amen!!!

  11. Carolyn Ziebert says:

    Thank you -we need to put politics aside and address human dignity and respect for all. And agree with others that your nieces need to see this before dating relationships begin. They need to learn to speak up for safety – in this case their own.

  12. Lisa Meder says:

    I really appreciate your posts – thoughtful, intelligent, and spot on.

  13. Sumathi Thiyagarajan says:

    Dr. Gorelick – Many thanks for this post. As a first-generation immigrant and a mother of two daughters I struggled a lot with what happened this week. My parents came to this country 35+ years ago because they thought it offered the best possible environment for themselves and their daughters. With a level-head, I still believe that to be the case and am hopeful/planful about the future. I’m grateful to know there are leaders within CHW who are willing to truly voice their opinions and beliefs in a respectful way. I hope to share this post with my kids in the future as well.

  14. Chris Lutze says:

    As a mom of 2 boys, I esp. appreciated the statement:.. Sexism and misogyny are not carried on the Y chromosome! As a strong advocate of safety, I would love to see this published in the NY TImes, Wallstreet, Journal, Milw Sentinel, etc. Dr. Gorelick,,
    you are another reason I’m so proud to work at CHW!

  15. Bradley Kirschner says:

    Fantastic. As a father of three (girls), as a husband, as a son, as a pediatrician, I whole-heartedly agree!

  16. Pat Donohoue says:

    Marc thank you — this is spot on. I appreciate your message and your eloquence. You are the voice of many men speaking up for the respect and success many women. May your sentiment spread widely, including Pennsylvania Avenue.

  17. Lisa Makowski says:

    Thank you for sharing this message, it truly resonates.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: